Rick Gehman highlighted Joe Highsmith as a potential high-upside play at the Arnold Palmer Invitational due to his recent improvements in putting. Gehman discussed Highsmith's experimentation with different putting grips, which led to gains of 8.2 strokes putting over his last four starts. While Gehman doesn't expect Highsmith to contend for a win this week, he emphasized that Highsmith is a very solid tee-to-green player whose results depend entirely on his putting. At a nearly minimum price of $6,200, Highsmith could provide significant value if his putting improvement continues.

Jason Rouslin recommended including Joe Highsmith in DFS lineups, particularly for GPP tournaments. Highsmith, priced at $6,200, is coming off a strong performance with excellent iron play. Rouslin believes that if Highsmith continues to hit his irons well and keeps the ball in the fairway, he has the potential to finish in the top 20 again. Despite the stronger field this week, Highsmith's recent form makes him a value pick at his low price point.

Redkacheek cautioned against high expectations for Joe Highsmith, noting that he may struggle on the challenging greens at Bay Hill. While acknowledging Highsmith's strong tee-to-green game and recent good performance, Redkacheek pointed out that the greens at Bay Hill are tougher than those at PGA National, and Highsmith may find it difficult to make crucial putts, especially being his first time playing on fast Bermuda greens rolling at 13. He suggested including Highsmith in player pools for larger tournaments but advised tempering expectations due to potential putting struggles.

Pat Mayo highlighted Joe Highsmith as a strong candidate for the 2025 Puerto Rico Open if he does not qualify for the Arnold Palmer Invitational. Highsmith rallied into contention at the Cognizant event on Saturday and is currently seventh entering the final round for the Aon swing. Mayo noted that if Highsmith doesn't secure a spot in the API, he would be one of the better options at Puerto Rico due to his recent form and strong play.

Brian Kirschner said he is picking Joe Highsmith at +11000 based on Highsmith’s 17th-place finish in Mexico, where he gained six strokes ball-striking. Kirschner noted that Highsmith has gained on approach in three consecutive starts, making him a worthwhile longshot at PGA National.